Posted by: adbhutam | May 19, 2019

Siddhanta Traya Sarah ‘ஸித்தாந்த த்ரய ஸாரம்’

Siddhanta Traya Sarah is a unique book that renders the three siddhanta-s namely Advaita, Vishishtadvaita and Dvaita in a condensed form. MM Sri R.Krishnamurthy Sastrigal has compiled, rather translated from the originals, in Tamil for the benefit of those who cannot approach the three doctrines in their original form.

Swami Vidyaranya’s ‘Vaiyasika Nyaya maalaa’ which gives in verse form the essence of each adhikaraNam of the Brahma sutras is the source for the Advaita section.

Vidwan Kapisthalam Sri Desikachar’s ‘shaariraka adhikarana ratnaavali’ is the source for the section on Vishishtadvaita.

Sri Raghavendra Tirtha’s ‘Nyaya Muktavali’ is the source book for the Dvaita siddhanta section in this book.

The book is unique in this respect that it offers in one book, of 500 plus pages in Tamil, an overview of the three doctrines.

The attached 13 images contain the commendation letters of Vidwan Mani Dravid Sastrigal in Sanskrit, Vidwan K.E.Devanathan’s Tamil article on his appreciation of the rendering of the Vishishtadvaita section (by pointing out some ten instances where the author’s excellence is very noteworthy) and Dr.Haridasa Bhatta’s letter in Sanskrit is a note of commendation for the Dvaita section and the entire book. The blurb has a profile of Sri Krishnamurthy Sastrigal.

Sri Krishnamurthy Sastrigal’s note tracing the genesis of the book and its completion scans several interesting incidents, in Tamil.

As several persons have suggested that the book deserves a translation into English and Kannada and perhaps Telugu and Hindi, I request those who can take up this work, from the three doctrines, to come forward. This way, the burden will get distributed. Those who are interested may kindly contact me off line to discuss the modalities.

I request members who know Tamil to kindly buy this invaluable book which is available at a subsidised price of Rs.300. The book, hard-bound, is very elegantly produced. Each siddhanta is printed in a different color. Copies can be had at the residence of Sri Krishnamurthi Sastrigal, close to the Madras Sanskrit College, Mylapore, Chennai 600 004.

Here is the link to the book release function held at Chennai where a summary of the Brahmasutra bhashya according to Advaita and Vishishtadvaita has been delivered by Vidwans Sri Mani Dravid Sastrigal and Sri K.E.Devanathan in Tamil. Dr.Haridas Bhatta (Dvaita vedanta) could not be present at the function due to personal reasons. Prof.K.Ramasubramanian (esteemed member of BVP), the illustrious son of Sri Krishnamurthy Sastrigal, has given the introductory talk. It is a very enjoyable function in deed:

Kindly share the information with all those who are interested in the Book.

See the images uploaded as a file in this link: https://groups.google.com/forum/…

warm regards


Responses

  1. The vishishtadvaita guy pretended to be non-fanatic in this setting – he is quite different before Iyengar audiences.

  2. Are dvaita guys any different?

    • Within their circles they shower abuses on Shankaracharya and Advaita. But in the presence of other school scholars they put up a benign face. This is generally the norm of the two schools.

  3. Can you give me list of this gen`s Advaita scholars?I know these two MM Mani Dravid and MM Vishwanath Gopalkrishna Shastri.Any more MM Advaita scholars?Who are still alive?

    • These are a few known to me: Sarvashri Vidwan Maheswaran, Vasudevan, Kuppa Vishwanatha Sastry, M.L.Narasimhamurthy, Ganesh Ishwara Bhatta, Sathyanarayana, Bangalore, Satish Bhat, N Delhi, Srihari Dhaygude, Ramana Sharma….

  4. Can you please suggest where I can procure (apparently copies sold out when I enquired in Jan 2022 with Sankrit college / Sastrigal) or to read in Bangalore? Many Thanks.

    • I think you can contact Sri Sastrigal, Chennai, and ask him if he has any copies left. I am in Bangalore and have a copy with me. I can lend it to you for reading.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

%d bloggers like this: