Posted by: adbhutam | December 10, 2009

A STUDY OF CAUSE AND EFFECT IN VEDANTA

SrIgurubhyo namaH

Characteristics of KAraNa, Cause and Kaarya, Effect

The study of Vedanta involves a correct understanding of the concept of Cause and Effect.  These are called ‘kAraNam’ and ‘kAryam’ respectively.  The final purport of Vedanta is Advaitam and the very concept of cause-effect is unreal.  Yet, in order to get the proper grasping of the Non-dual truth, the Vedanta adopts the method of cause-effect.  Once the truth is grasped, the concept and the method of cause-effect are dropped. The Mandukya Upanishad, in the crucial seventh mantra naantaH prajnam… presents the Ultimate Truth, Turiya, as kArya-kAraNa-vilakShaNam. Brahman, the Ultimate Truth, is neither the cause of anything nor the effect of anything.

This study of the characteristics of the cause and effect is undertaken as an example in order to apply them to Brahman and the world and finally appreciate the nature of Brahman and understand the nature of the world. These characteristics are enumerated below:

  1. KaaraNam Ekam, One  – Kaaryam anekam, many
  2. kAraNam Nityam, eternal  – kARyam anityam, ephemeral
  3. kARaNam Saaram, essence, substantial –  kAryam asaaram, insubstantial
  4. KaaraNam Satyam, real – kAryam asatyam, unreal

The example of gold, the cause and gold-ornaments, the effects, is taken up to elucidate the above.

  1. Whatever be the number of ornaments, the material gold is one only.  Thus, the effect, kAryam, ornaments have anekatvam, multiplicity and the cause, kAraNam, gold is ekam, one only.
  2. While ornaments keep changing, whenever one decides to ‘convert, remake’ a bangle into a chain and ring and so on, the material gold does not undergo change.  That is, what was called a bangle is now called a chain but what was gold in a bangle is still gold in the chain.  Thus gold is nityam, eternal and the ornaments are anityam, ephemeral.
  3. Gold alone is the substance, the substantial material, in all the ornaments.  The name and form of the ornament is insubstantial, immaterial.  When considering the worth, value, security of the ornaments one possesses, the individual name and form of ornaments are disregarded and only the content of gold in them is calculated.  Thus, what is disregarded, the name and form, is insubstantial, asaaram, and that which is counted, considered, valued alone is substantial, saaram.
  4. Gold is the ‘real’ thing and the ornaments are ‘false’.  This is because we say ‘bangle is’ and ‘is not’ referring to the presence and the absence of the bangle-name and form.  But gold is always referred to as ‘is’ and never comes to be called ‘is not’.  Whichever object swerves from its initially determined state is false, asatyam, mithyaa, and that which never gives up its originally determined state is alone true, satyam. (Read an article titled ‘The world is anitya, but is it mithya?’  at: 
    https://adbhutam.wordpress.com/2009/08/05/the-world-is-anitya-but-is-it-mithya/

The above four characteristics can be applied to the Cause, Brahman, and the effect, the world.

  1. Brahman the cause is only One and the world, the effect, is variegated. One can even talk about several worlds, considering the past ones that have perished in pralaya. Brahman is Advaita and the world is dvaita.
  2. Brahman is  eternal, nityam and the world is ephemeral, the constantly changing one.
  3. Brahman is the substance of the world; the world as a name and form is insubstantial.  In deep sleep we discard the world and repose in the Atman, the Self, our love for the world and our body-mind notwithstanding.  Also, more importantly, the realization of Truth demands our ‘giving up’ the world.  Only he who is able to consider the world as insubstantial can succeed in realizing Brahman, the Substance.
  4. Brahman is the Truth, Real, Satyam and the world in mithyA, unreal.
  5. Viveka, discrimination is the result of the consideration of the Satyam-mithyA aspect of Brahman-world.
  6. Vairagyam, dispassion, desirelessness, is the result of the consideration of the nityam-anityam aspect of Brahman-world.
  7. Vairagyam is strengthened by considering the essential, substantial nature of Brahman and the insubstantial nature of the world, resulting in shama, mind-control, dama, sense-control, uparati, withdrawal from actions to fulfill unnecessary goals, titikshaa, forbearance in the face of difficult situations, shraddhaa, deep faith, conviction, in the teaching of the scripture and the preceptor, samaadhAnam, abidance in longing-free equipoise.  All these will result in reinforcing mumukshutvam, the burning desire for release from bondage.

The above study results in these corollaries:

The deep study of the characteristics of cause and effect, applied to Vedanta, will enable the aspirant to focus his sadhana in the right direction.  He will consider what his own fundamental needs are:

  1. lasting peace
  2. lasting security
  3. lasting happiness

He comes to understand that these cannot be had by turning to the world.  The world is characterized by:

  1. variety
  2. beauty
  3. novelty
  4. unreliability
  5. ephemerality

The sadhaka sees the contrast and total unsuitability, incompatibility of the world with reference to what he fundamentally seeks.  He learns to intelligently ‘use’ the world but not lean upon the world.  The world is compared to a beautiful chair, artistically ornamented and displayed in the showcase of a shop. One likes to buy it for use in the office or home.  The shopkeeper, while negotiating the price, casually remarks that the chair is made of card board and is very light in weight.  He says it is a fine piece of curio and one can do anything with it except sitting on it.

With this crucial knowledge about the world, the aspirant learns not to rely on the world for security, peace and happiness.  This is the avowed purpose of the study of the nature of the cause and effect.

Humble pranams to Pujya Swami Paramarthananda-ji whose elucidation inspired the above study.

Related Reading:

  1. An article titled: AdhyAropa ApavAda available at:

http://www.advaita.org.uk/discourses/teachers/adhyaropa_subrahmanian.htm

2.  An article titled: Attributes and Substantive at:

https://adbhutam.wordpress.com/2009/07/25/attributes-and-substantive/

Om Tat Sat


Responses

  1. […] A STUDY OF CAUSE AND EFFECT IN VEDANTA « Adbhutam's Blog A highly technical study, indeed: […]

    • Thanks for the observation.

  2. It looks like you are a real pro. Did you study about the topic? haha..

    • Yes. This is a part of the overall study of Advaita Vedanta. Thanks for your query.

  3. can material science of the senses help achieve advaita which is beyond
    the senses

    • Material science, as the name itself suggests, is about matter while Brahman, the Atman, the subject of Advaita, is not matter but spirit that knows matter. The quest has to be about the knower of the material phenomena. Only then one can achieve Advaita.

  4. is brahman bound by material, scientific & universal laws.

    • Brahman is not bound by any laws. Only that which is within creation can be subject to laws.

  5. how can ever changing material & scientific laws explain brahman which is
    eternal & everlasting

    • As stated earlier, the unchanging, unobjectifiable Brahman cannot be brought within the purview of material and scientific laws.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

%d bloggers like this: